MailOptin wins 3 of the 3 points we can measure. Here's how they compare on price, features, ratings and deals.
| Feature | MailOptin | OptinMonster |
|---|---|---|
| Our score | 8.5/10 (better) | 5.1/10 |
| Starts at | $99/year (better) | $210/year |
| Free version | Yes (better) | No |
| Refund window | 14 days | 14 days |
| Billing | Subscription | Subscription |
| Active installs | 10K+ | – |
| Last Black Friday | – | 60% off |
| Category | Email marketing | Email marketing |
| Vendor | MailOptin | OptinMonster |
| Black Friday 2026 | Not announced | Not announced |
StandardStarts here
$99/year
1 site sites
Pro
$289/year
3 sites sites
Agency
$499/year
Unlimited sites
BasicStarts here
$210/year
1 site
Plus
$570/year
2 sites
Pro
$870/year
3 sites
Not enough Reddit discussion yet.
Reddit mentions of OptinMonster are negative, with users reporting it showing up on sites where they did not install it. One post links it to compromised sites through bundled plugins, and another says it was hard to remove once installed.
On our comparison MailOptin comes out ahead on 3 of 3 measurable points. The right pick still depends on what you build.
MailOptin starts at $99/year and OptinMonster starts at $210/year.
Both are on our Black Friday tracker. OptinMonster was 60% off last year.
Convert website visitors into subscribers and WordPress users, send one-off newsletters, and create automated, event-triggered follow-up emails.
Most Powerful Lead Generation Software for Marketers