Smush Pro vs W3 Total Cache Pro

Smush Pro wins 3 of the 3 points we can measure. Here's how they compare on price, features, ratings and deals.

At a glance

FeatureSmush ProW3 Total Cache Pro
Our score8.5/10 (better)8.2/10
Starts at$50/year (better)$99/year
Free versionYesYes
Refund window30 days30 days
BillingFree + paid plansSubscription
Active installs1M+ (better)900K+
Last Black Friday––
CategoryPerformancePerformance
VendorWPMU DEVBoldGrid
Black Friday 2026Not announcedNot announced

Which should you choose?

Choose Smush Pro if…

  • Site owners who want smaller, faster images
  • Agencies optimizing client sites
  • You want the lower starting price

Choose W3 Total Cache Pro if…

  • Site owners who want advanced caching on one site
  • Agencies managing several client sites

Features

Smush Pro

  • Compression levels
  • Next-gen formats
  • Automatic optimization
  • Lazy load and preload
  • Global CDN
  • Directory Smush

W3 Total Cache Pro

  • Full site delivery
  • Remove unused CSS and JS
  • Eliminate render-blocking CSS
  • Delay scripts
  • WebP image conversion
  • Cache hit statistics
  • REST API caching

Pros and cons

Smush Pro

  • Free version available on WordPress.org
  • Plans range from one site to unlimited sites
  • Includes CDN and next-gen image formats
  • Free version limits each image to 5MB; Pro allows 256MB
  • Premium membership bundles other WPMU DEV tools, not just Smush

W3 Total Cache Pro

  • Free version on WordPress.org with 900,000+ active installs
  • Full set of page, CDN and asset optimisation features
  • 30-day money-back guarantee
  • Multi-site licences at 5 and 10 sites
  • Pro features need an annual licence
  • Bulk licence pricing is not published on the page

Pricing plans

Smush Pro

  • Pro Basic

    $50/year

    1 site sites

    • Image compression Ultra 5X
    • Next-gen image formats
    • 119-location CDN
  • Pro Standard

    $75/year

    3 sites sites

    • Image compression Ultra 5X
    • Next-gen image formats
    • 119-location CDN
  • PremiumStarts here

    $4.99/month

    Unlimited sites

    • All WPMU DEV Pro plugins
    • Unlimited 24/7 expert support
    • Unlimited backups and CDN

W3 Total Cache Pro

  • 1 Site LicenseStarts here

    $99/year

    1 site

    • Covers 1 site
    • Annual licence
  • 5 Site Licenses

    $350/year

    5 sites

    • Covers 5 sites
    • Includes 1 free plugin configuration ($125 value)
  • 10 Site Licenses

    $500/year

    10 sites

    • Covers 10 sites
    • Includes 2 free plugin configurations ($250 value)

Smush Pro vs W3 Total Cache Pro questions

Is Smush Pro better than W3 Total Cache Pro?

On our comparison Smush Pro comes out ahead on 3 of 3 measurable points. The right pick still depends on what you build.

Which is cheaper, Smush Pro or W3 Total Cache Pro?

Smush Pro starts at $50/year and W3 Total Cache Pro starts at $99/year.

Can I get Smush Pro or W3 Total Cache Pro cheaper on Black Friday?

Both are on our Black Friday tracker. We'll add each discount the moment it goes live.

Both products

Smush Pro

8.5/10

Smush Pro compresses images, converts them to next-gen formats and serves them through a CDN.

Free version
Yes
Price
From $50/year
Category
Performance

Related comparisons