Top-Rated WordPress Donation Plugin for Faster and Easier Fundraising
- Free version
- Yes
- Price
- From $69/year
- Category
- eCommerce
Not announcedBlack Friday deal for Charitable
Charitable vs YayExtra
Charitable wins 2 of the 3 points we can measure. Here's how they compare on price, features, ratings and deals.
At a glance
| Feature | Charitable | YayExtra |
|---|---|---|
| Our score | 8.7/10 (better) | 7.4/10 |
| Starts at | $69/year (better) | $99/year |
| Free version | Yes | Yes |
| Refund window | 14 days | 30 days (better) |
| Billing | Subscription | Subscription |
| Active installs | 10K+ | – |
| Last Black Friday | – | 40% off |
| Category | eCommerce | eCommerce |
| Vendor | WPCharitable | YayCommerce |
| Black Friday 2026 | Not announced | Not announced |
Which should you choose?
Choose Charitable if…
- Nonprofits running online donation campaigns
- Agencies building fundraising sites for clients
- You want the lower starting price
Choose YayExtra if…
- WooCommerce stores selling personalised products
- Stores offering engraving or custom options
- Shops that need conditional product forms
Features
Charitable
- Customizable donation forms
- Full donation management
- Recurring donations
- Payment gateways
- Donor dashboard and receipts
- Peer to peer fundraising
YayExtra
- Custom product add-ons
- Conditional fields and rules
- Fixed or percentage pricing
- File upload
- Delivery date and time picker
- Handling fee
- Live product page preview
Pros and cons
Charitable
- Free version on WordPress.org
- Unlimited campaigns and donors on every paid plan
- No transaction fees on the Basic plan
- 14-day money-back guarantee
- Peer to peer fundraising and crowdfunding need the Pro plan at 199 per year
- Multisite and client management need the Elite plan at 299 per year
- Paid plans are annual subscriptions
YayExtra
- Conditional fields and rules for flexible option logic
- Supports file upload, delivery date and time picker fields
- Preview the product page before publishing
- Product subtotal updates as options are chosen
- 30-day money-back guarantee
- Advanced fields and rules are only in the paid Pro plans
- Single site yearly plan costs 99 per year
- Unlimited lifetime plan costs 999
Pricing plans
Charitable
BasicStarts here
$69/year
1 site
- Unlimited campaigns
- Unlimited donors
- No transaction fees
Plus
$99/year
1 site
- Recurring donations
- Annual receipts
- Gift Aid
Pro
$199/year
1 site
- Peer to peer fundraising
- Crowdfunding
- Stripe Connect
YayExtra
Single SiteStarts here
$99/year
1 site
5 Sites
$199/year
5 sites
Unlimited Sites
$499/year
Unlimited sites
Charitable vs YayExtra questions
Is Charitable better than YayExtra?
On our comparison Charitable comes out ahead on 2 of 3 measurable points. The right pick still depends on what you build.
Which is cheaper, Charitable or YayExtra?
Charitable starts at $69/year and YayExtra starts at $99/year.
Can I get Charitable or YayExtra cheaper on Black Friday?
Both are on our Black Friday tracker. YayExtra was 40% off last year.
Both products
YayExtra allows customers to personalize products with customizable options and additional services to boost sales.
- Free version
- Yes
- Price
- From $99/year
- Category
- eCommerce
Not announcedBlack Friday deal for YayExtra