User Approval Management WordPress Plugin
- Free version
- Yes
- Price
- From $59.99/year
- Category
- Security
Not announcedBlack Friday deal for New User Approve
New User Approve vs Wordfence Premium
Wordfence Premium wins 2 of the 3 points we can measure. Here's how they compare on price, features, ratings and deals.
At a glance
| Feature | New User Approve | Wordfence Premium |
|---|---|---|
| Our score | 7.9/10 | 8/10 (better) |
| Starts at | $59.99/year (better) | $149/year |
| Free version | Yes | Yes |
| Refund window | 14 days | – |
| Billing | Subscription | Free + paid plans |
| Active installs | 20K+ | 5M+ (better) |
| Last Black Friday | – | – |
| Category | Security | Security |
| Vendor | New User Approve | Defiant Inc |
| Black Friday 2026 | Not announced | Not announced |
Which should you choose?
Choose New User Approve if…
- Membership and gated sites
- Sites that get spam sign-ups
- You want the lower starting price
Choose Wordfence Premium if…
- Self-managed WordPress sites that need paid firewall updates
- Site owners who want hands-on help through Care or Response
Features
New User Approve
- Manual registration approval
- Invitation codes
- Auto-approve by role
- Email domain allow and block lists
- Customizable email notifications
- Deadline-based registration
Wordfence Premium
- Real-time firewall updates
- Premium IP blocklist
- Country blocking
- Audit log history
- Premium support
Pros and cons
New User Approve
- Free version listed on WordPress.org
- Manual approval stops bot and spam sign-ups before access is granted
- Yearly plans start at $59.99
- 14-day money-back guarantee
- Email domain lists and deadline registration need the Business plan
- No Trustpilot or G2 rating found
Wordfence Premium
- Free version covers core protection
- Premium adds real-time firewall rule updates
- Paid Care and Response plans are available
- Premium is priced per site per year
- Care and Response cost several times the Premium price
- Premium rose from $119 to $149 a year in December 2024
Pricing plans
New User Approve
BasicStarts here
$59.99/year
- Manual approval of registrations
- Auto-approve selected user roles
- Invite-only registration
Professional
$79.99/year
- Customizable email notifications
- Bulk-generate and email invite codes
- Priority support
Business
$99.99/year
- Whitelist and blacklist email domains
- Deadline-based registration
- Priority support
Wordfence Premium
Wordfence PremiumStarts here
$149/year
1 site
- Real-time firewall rule and malware signature updates
- Premium IP blocklist
- Country blocking
Wordfence Care
$590/year
1 site
- Installation, configuration and optimization
- Monitoring and hands-on support
- Initial security audit
Wordfence Response
$1,250/year
1 site
- 1-hour response time
- Available 24/7/365
- Incident response and hands-on support
What Reddit says
New User Approve
Not enough Reddit discussion yet.
Wordfence Premium
Reddit users often call Wordfence popular and widely recommended, but several say it misses infected files and database records. One site owner reported infections that went unreported by alert emails and began looking for an alternative.
New User Approve vs Wordfence Premium questions
Is New User Approve better than Wordfence Premium?
On our comparison Wordfence Premium comes out ahead on 2 of 3 measurable points. The right pick still depends on what you build.
Which is cheaper, New User Approve or Wordfence Premium?
New User Approve starts at $59.99/year and Wordfence Premium starts at $149/year.
Can I get New User Approve or Wordfence Premium cheaper on Black Friday?
Both are on our Black Friday tracker. We'll add each discount the moment it goes live.
Both products
Wordfence Premium adds real-time firewall rule and malware signature updates, a premium IP blocklist and country blocking to the free WordPress security plugin.
- Free version
- Yes
- Price
- From $149/year
- Category
- Security
Not announcedBlack Friday deal for Wordfence Premium