The Freaky Blog
MemberMouse7.4/10Paymattic8.3/10

MemberMouse vs Paymattic

Paymattic wins 3 of the 4 points we can measure. Here's how they compare on price, features, ratings and deals.

At a glance

FeatureMemberMousePaymattic
Our score7.4/108.3/10 (better)
Starts at$149.50/year$83/year (better)
Free versionNoYes (better)
Refund window14 days–
BillingSubscriptionFree + paid plans
Active installs–3K+
Last Black Friday65% off (better)50% off
CategoryMembership & LMSMembership & LMS
VendorMemberMousePaymattic
Black Friday 2026Not announcedNot announced

Which should you choose?

Choose MemberMouse if…

  • Course creators selling memberships
  • Membership site owners with recurring billing
MemberMouse reviewVisit MemberMouse (opens in a new tab)

Choose Paymattic if…

  • Small businesses that take payments on WordPress
  • Nonprofits that collect donations
  • You want to start free
  • You want the lower starting price
Paymattic reviewVisit Paymattic (opens in a new tab)

Features

MemberMouse

  • Membership content protection
  • Recurring billing and payments
  • Courses
  • One-click upsells
  • Email integrations
  • Analytics and reporting

Paymattic

  • Subscriptions and one-time payments
  • Global and local payment gateways
  • Recurring and one-time donations
  • Drag and drop form builder
  • Customer and donor dashboards
  • Coupons and currency support
  • Webhooks and notifications

Pros and cons

MemberMouse

  • Several payment processors supported, including Stripe and PayPal
  • Seven email service integrations and a Zapier integration on every plan
  • Full analytics and reporting suite on the Pro plan
  • No free version or free trial listed
  • Quizzes and certificates need the Plus plan at 249.50 per year
  • Authorize.Net and ClickBank payments need the Pro plan at 349.50 per year

Paymattic

  • Free version available on WordPress.org
  • Supports subscriptions and one-time payments
  • Lifetime plans are available for each license tier
  • Paid plans renew each year unless you buy a lifetime license
  • No money-back guarantee is listed on the pricing page

Pricing plans

MemberMouse

  • BasicStarts here

    $149.50/year

    • Stripe payments
    • Courses for MemberMouse
    • 7 email integrations

  • Plus

    $249.50/year

    • PayPal and Braintree payments
    • Social signup and login
    • Quizzes and certificates for courses

  • Pro

    $349.50/year

    • Authorize.Net and ClickBank payments
    • Full analytics and reporting suite
    • Priority email support

Paymattic

  • PersonalStarts here

    $83/year

    1 site

    • 1 domain
    • 1 year of plugin updates
    • 1 year of priority support

  • Agency

    $167/year

    20 sites

    • 20 domains
    • 1 year of plugin updates
    • 1 year of priority support

  • Unlimited

    $251/year

    Unlimited sites

    • Unlimited domains
    • 1 year of plugin updates
    • 1 year of priority support

MemberMouse vs Paymattic questions

Is MemberMouse better than Paymattic?

On our comparison Paymattic comes out ahead on 3 of 4 measurable points. The right pick still depends on what you build.

Which is cheaper, MemberMouse or Paymattic?

MemberMouse starts at $149.50/year and Paymattic starts at $83/year.

Can I get MemberMouse or Paymattic cheaper on Black Friday?

Both are on our Black Friday tracker. MemberMouse was 65% off last year. Paymattic was 50% off last year.

Both products

Related comparisons