WordPress Digital eCommerce
- Free version
- Yes
- Price
- From $99.50/year
- Category
- eCommerce
Not announcedBlack Friday deal for Easy Digital Downloads
Easy Digital Downloads vs YayExtra
YayExtra wins 2 of the 3 points we can measure. Here's how they compare on price, features, ratings and deals.
At a glance
| Feature | Easy Digital Downloads | YayExtra |
|---|---|---|
| Our score | 7.8/10 (better) | 7.4/10 |
| Starts at | $99.50/year | $99/year (better) |
| Free version | Yes | Yes |
| Refund window | 14 days | 30 days (better) |
| Billing | Free + paid plans | Subscription |
| Active installs | 40K+ | – |
| Last Black Friday | – | 40% off |
| Category | eCommerce | eCommerce |
| Vendor | Easy Digital Downloads | YayCommerce |
| Black Friday 2026 | Not announced | Not announced |
Which should you choose?
Choose Easy Digital Downloads if…
- Selling digital downloads and subscriptions
- Sellers who want no per-sale platform fees
Choose YayExtra if…
- WooCommerce stores selling personalised products
- Stores offering engraving or custom options
- Shops that need conditional product forms
- You want the lower starting price
Features
Easy Digital Downloads
- Unlimited products
- No platform fees
- Payment gateways
- Subscriptions and free trials
- Discount codes
- Software licensing
YayExtra
- Custom product add-ons
- Conditional fields and rules
- Fixed or percentage pricing
- File upload
- Delivery date and time picker
- Handling fee
- Live product page preview
Pros and cons
Easy Digital Downloads
- Free Lite version on WordPress.org
- No platform fees on any plan
- 14-day money-back guarantee on paid plans
- Personal plan at 99.5 a year includes subscriptions and abandoned cart recovery
- Paid plans are annual, and no lifetime plan is listed on the pricing page
- Software licensing and the multi-vendor marketplace need the Professional plan or above
- Trustpilot average is 3.5 out of 5 from 22 reviews
YayExtra
- Conditional fields and rules for flexible option logic
- Supports file upload, delivery date and time picker fields
- Preview the product page before publishing
- Product subtotal updates as options are chosen
- 30-day money-back guarantee
- Advanced fields and rules are only in the paid Pro plans
- Single site yearly plan costs 99 per year
- Unlimited lifetime plan costs 999
Pricing plans
Easy Digital Downloads
PersonalStarts here
$99.50/year
1 site
- Subscriptions and free trials
- Abandoned cart recovery
- EU VAT compliance
Extended
$199.50/year
1 site
- Multi-currency support
- Content restriction
- Customer reviews
Professional
$299.50/year
2 sites
- Software licensing and API
- Multi-vendor marketplace
- Post-purchase funnels
YayExtra
Single SiteStarts here
$99/year
1 site
5 Sites
$199/year
5 sites
Unlimited Sites
$499/year
Unlimited sites
What Reddit says
Easy Digital Downloads
Reddit users compare Easy Digital Downloads with WooCommerce for selling digital files, and several pick it as the simpler, download-focused option. Reported issues include checkout breaking when WP-Cron is disabled, and author and date showing on product pages, while some users were warned it has problems.
YayExtra
Not enough Reddit discussion yet.
Easy Digital Downloads vs YayExtra questions
Is Easy Digital Downloads better than YayExtra?
On our comparison YayExtra comes out ahead on 2 of 3 measurable points. The right pick still depends on what you build.
Which is cheaper, Easy Digital Downloads or YayExtra?
Easy Digital Downloads starts at $99.50/year and YayExtra starts at $99/year.
Can I get Easy Digital Downloads or YayExtra cheaper on Black Friday?
Both are on our Black Friday tracker. YayExtra was 40% off last year.
Both products
YayExtra allows customers to personalize products with customizable options and additional services to boost sales.
- Free version
- Yes
- Price
- From $99/year
- Category
- eCommerce
Not announcedBlack Friday deal for YayExtra